Business Development Underwriting Partner
Company : Nautilus Insurance Company
Location : Centerport, NY
Job Type : Full Time / Part Time
Date Posted : 31 December 2025
Company Details
Berkley One is a modern insurance provider for a modern generation of affluence. We serve clients who live dynamic, adventurous lives and expect their insurance experience to match. Our mission is to deliver highly personalized risk and claims management through a blend of expert independent agents, cutting-edge digital tools, and the strength of the Berkley brand.
Why Join Us?
At Berkley One, you’ll be part of a forward-thinking team that’s reimagining personal insurance. We’re building solutions that are as sophisticated and agile as the clients we serve—individuals and families who value innovation, simplicity, and exceptional service. You’ll collaborate with passionate professionals, leverage modern technology, and help shape the future of our industry.
What We Value
- A client-first mindset with a passion for delivering exceptional experiences
- Curiosity, creativity, and a drive to challenge the status quo
- Collaboration across disciplines to build smarter, more intuitive solutions
- Integrity, expertise, and a commitment to excellence
Join us in creating a new standard in personal insurance—where protection meets possibility.
This role involves frequent travel within Long Island and NYC therefore, this role is meant for those who are based in the local area.
#LI-AV1 #LI-Remote
The Company is an equal employment opportunity employer.
Responsibilities
As a Business Development Underwriting Partner, you'll be a key individual contributor to the Berkley One brand, responsible for driving profitable growth through expert underwriting and strategic business development. The ideal candidate will blend deep underwriting expertise with a passion for building and nurturing agency relationships, contributing to both the financial success and brand presence of Berkley One.
What you can expect:
- Culture of innovation, teamwork, supportive colleagues and leaders willing to invest in talent
- Internal mobility opportunities
- Visibility to senior leaders and partnership with cross functional teams
- Opportunity to impact change
- Benefits – competitive compensation, paid time off, comprehensive wellness benefits and programs, employer funded health savings account, profit sharing, 401k, paid parental leave, employee stock purchase plan, tuition assistance and professional continuing education
We'll count on you for:
Underwriting & Risk Evaluation
- Underwrite new business daily, selecting and pricing risks aligned with profitability goals.
- Collaborate with risk management to assess exposures and recommend solutions that enhance risk quality.
- Utilize advanced underwriting tools and analytics to monitor portfolio performance and inform decisions.
- Educate agents on Berkley One’s risk appetite and guide appropriate risk selection.
Business Development & Agency Management
- Execute agency management strategies to meet or exceed growth and profit targets by state and agent/broker.
- Identify and appoint new agent/broker partners; manage out non-performing agents.
- Lead agency business planning focused on new business, retention, hit ratio, profit, and efficiency.
- Develop and maintain a pipeline of profitable target market opportunities in the territory.
- Provide quote coaching and new business support to agency partners.
- Track agency performance and adjust strategies to maximize revenue and brand impact.
Strategic Collaboration & Brand Building
- Partner with Distribution and Marketing teams to co-develop growth strategies and enhance market presence.
- Execute initiatives related to lead generation, networking, events, campaigns, and brand storytelling.
- Build strong connections between agency partners and internal teams to ensure exceptional service delivery.
- Contribute to the development of distribution capabilities aligned with Berkley One’s strategic goals.
- Gather and disseminate market intelligence, broker insights, and competitive analysis to inform broader organizational strategy.
Innovation & Continuous Improvement
- Identify opportunities for innovation in underwriting and business development practices.
- Challenge norms and contribute to process optimization and organizational priorities.
Travel Requirement
- Travel throughout the assigned territory is required, averaging 40% each week.
- Other work as assigned
Qualifications
What you need to have:
- Bachelor’s degree (BA or BS) or equivalent professional experience
- 3–5 years of successful agency management and underwriting experience in the high-net-worth personal lines
- Exceptional communication skills—verbal and written—with the ability to adapt to diverse audiences
- Strong customer-centric mindset with empathy for insureds and agents
- Highly organized, accountable, and composed under pressure
- Collaborative and innovative, with natural curiosity and drive for continuous improvement
- Tech-savvy and proficient in underwriting tools and analytics
- Valid drivers license
- Able and willing to meet travel requirements
Additional Company Details
We do not accept any unsolicited resumes from external recruiting agencies or firms. The company offers a competitive compensation plan and robust benefits package for full time regular employees which for this role include: • Base Salary Range: $110-130k • Eligible to participate in annual discretionary bonus. • Benefits: Company Provided Fleet Vehicle, Health, Dental, Vision, Life, Disability, Wellness, Paid Time Off, 401(k) and generous Profit-Sharing plans. The actual salary for this position will be determined by a number of factors, including the scope, complexity and location of the role; the skills, education, training, credentials and experience of the candidate; and other conditions of employmentSponsorship Details
Sponsorship not Offered for this RoleRelated Jobs
Associate, Corporate Business Development (Mergers & Acquisitions)
Centric Brands Inc.
Top trending job titles hiring now
Popular Searches for Business Development
Frequently asked questions
Success in this role hinges on blending underwriting expertise with savvy agency relationship-building, especially in the competitive Long Island and NYC regions. Proficiency in risk evaluation, strong communication skills, and local market knowledge are crucial to navigate the dynamic insurance landscape here.
Professionals typically advance by expanding their portfolio management skills and strategic influence, often progressing into senior underwriting leadership or regional business development roles. Continuous learning and networking within high-net-worth personal lines are key for growth.
Daily tasks blend underwriting new business with hands-on agency support—evaluating risks, coaching partners on quotes, and refining strategies to surpass growth targets. Regular travel within Long Island and NYC is integral to maintaining strong, trusted agency relationships.
Nautilus emphasizes innovation and collaboration, encouraging this role to drive growth through modern underwriting techniques while fostering close internal and agency partnerships. The company supports professional development and rewards initiative aligned with its client-first philosophy.
Beyond competitive pay and benefits, Nautilus offers visibility to senior leadership, cross-functional teamwork, and internal mobility. The company’s culture promotes innovation and continuous improvement, empowering partners to shape underwriting and business strategies dynamically.
The expected base salary spans from $110,000 to $130,000 annually, reflecting the role’s specialized underwriting and agency management demands in the affluent Long Island market. Additional compensation may include bonuses, profit-sharing, and comprehensive benefits.
Traveling around 40% weekly across Long Island and NYC necessitates efficient time management and flexibility. Candidates based locally benefit from shorter commutes, enabling prompt client engagement and stronger agency connections crucial for business development success.
The region’s affluent demographic drives sustained demand for experts who can navigate complex personal lines underwriting and agency partnerships. While competition exists, opportunities remain robust for candidates adept at blending technical underwriting with strategic growth initiatives.