Senior Property Claims Adjuster
Company : Nautilus Insurance Company
Location : Scottsdale, AZ
Job Type : Full Time / Part Time
Date Posted : 31 December 2025
Company Details
Berkley One is a modern insurance provider for a modern generation of affluence. We serve clients who live dynamic, adventurous lives and expect their insurance experience to match. Our mission is to deliver highly personalized risk and claims management through a blend of expert independent agents, cutting-edge digital tools, and the strength of the Berkley brand.
Why Join Us?
At Berkley One, you’ll be part of a forward-thinking team that’s reimagining personal insurance. We’re building solutions that are as sophisticated and agile as the clients we serve—individuals and families who value innovation, simplicity, and exceptional service. You’ll collaborate with passionate professionals, leverage modern technology, and help shape the future of our industry.
What We Value
A client-first mindset with a passion for delivering exceptional experiencesCuriosity, creativity, and a drive to challenge the status quoCollaboration across disciplines to build smarter, more intuitive solutionsIntegrity, expertise, and a commitment to excellence
Join us in creating a new standard in personal insurance—where protection meets possibility.
#LI-AV1 #LI-HYBRID
This role will be based in our Phoenix, AZ office. We offer a hybrid work schedule with 4 days in the office; and 1 day remote where it makes sense to do so.
The Company is an equal employment opportunity employer.
Responsibilities
As a Senior Property Claims Adjuster, you'll be a key contributor to the Berkley One brand, requires proven claim technical, organizational and time management skills, self-direction, leadership and the ability to provide exceptional quality customer service. The Senior Property Desk Adjuster is responsible for quality handling and resolution of property claims including both volume and complex, high exposure claims in a timely, professional manner with emphasis on providing quality service. The ideal candidate will have experience in handling all manner and size of personal lines property claims from the desk. We'll trust you to provide service while assuring proper claim outcomes and expense management.
What you can expect:
- Culture of innovation, teamwork, supportive colleagues and leaders willing to invest in talent
- Internal mobility opportunities
- Visibility to senior leaders and partnership with cross functional teams
- Opportunity to impact change
- Benefits – competitive compensation, paid time off, comprehensive wellness benefits and programs, employer funded health savings account, profit sharing, 401k, paid parental leave, employee stock purchase plan, tuition assistance and professional continuing education
We'll count on you to:
- Appropriately manage assigned first party claims through coverage analysis, virtual desk adjusting, oversight of independent adjusters, other experts, reserving and resolution
- Identify and address coverage issues, complete investigation to determine cause & exposure, set timely reserves and develop detailed action plans
- Manage all experts and vendors assigned on claims including quality, service and expense.
- Write fair and equitable estimates in Symbility on appropriate losses
- Negotiate and convey claim settlements within authority limits
- Establish validity of claims submitted for payment through investigation, research and contact with policyholders, claimants and outside parties for additional information and documentation to evaluate and properly resolve claims
- Write denial letters, Reservation of Rights and other correspondence
- Maintain an effective diary system and document claim file activities in accordance with established procedures
- Pro-actively manage file inventory to ensure timely resolution of cases
- Deliver exceptional customer service to meet the needs of the insured, agent and all internal and external customers
- Perform administrative functions such as expense accounts and time off reporting as required
- Manage Independent Adjusters and experts on select claims
- Assist with the training of other internal and external adjusters on Berkley One best practices
- Catastrophe duty as needed
- Establish relationships within the broker community to promote our brand
- Perform other duties as assigned
Qualifications
What you need to have:
- Bachelors degree or equivalent industry experience
- Minimum 5 years of experience handling property insurance claims with an emphasis in working with High Net Worth customers
- Experience with automated claims systems
- Collaborative, you will coordinate with lead adjusters and managers on pending claim files requiring additional investigation and confirming coverage on our largest claims. You will also actively participate on CAT duty when needed and assist in overseeing the contractor referral program including re-inspections and quality reviews
- Pro-active, you will manage preferred vendors in order to drive continuous quality improvement
What makes you stand out:
- Broad knowledge of construction, estimating and estimating systems, Symbility preferred
- Incredible empathy and understanding of the needs of customers, both insureds and their agents alike. You will be an excellent, pro-active advocate for Berkley One customers and are passionate about their brand experience.
- Exceptional oral and written communication skills. Your communication style is flexible to the situation. You communicate clearly and with a purpose.
- Calm under pressure. You have excellent organizational and negotiation skills, integrity, and great follow-through on tasks. You are comfortable challenging norms while working collaboratively with colleagues at all levels of the organization.
- You have a strong sense of accountability, fun and adventure.
- Natural curiosity. You love learning how things work and you are always looking for innovative improvements.
Additional Company Details
We do not accept any unsolicited resumes from external recruiting agencies or firms. The company offers a competitive compensation plan and robust benefits package for full time regular employees. The actual salary for this position will be determined by a number of factors, including the scope, complexity and location of the role; the skills, education, training, credentials and experience of the candidate; and other conditions of employment.Sponsorship Details
Sponsorship not Offered for this RoleRelated Jobs
Top trending job titles hiring now
Frequently asked questions
Scottsdale’s insurance sector is growing steadily, increasing demand for skilled Senior Property Claims Adjusters. Local competition focuses on candidates with strong property claims expertise and customer service skills. Networking within the region’s broker community can provide an edge in securing these coveted roles.
In Arizona, certifications like the Adjuster License through the Department of Insurance and Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter (CPCU) designation are highly valued. These credentials demonstrate professionalism and deepen knowledge in claims handling, improving chances for senior roles in property claims.
Senior adjusters often navigate intricate claim investigations, balancing thorough coverage analysis with customer empathy. Managing vendor relationships and expense control adds complexity. The role demands sharp negotiation skills and maintaining composure under pressure to deliver fair settlements efficiently.
Senior adjusters bring advanced expertise in large-scale claim management, including leadership in coordinating experts and handling high-exposure losses. They exhibit refined organizational abilities and strategic decision-making, unlike entry-level adjusters who focus on foundational claim processing and learning coverage nuances.
Experienced Senior Property Claims Adjusters can progress into roles such as Claims Manager, Risk Analyst, or Specialty Claims Consultant. Leveraging leadership skills and deep claims knowledge opens pathways to strategic, supervisory, or cross-functional roles within insurance companies.
Nautilus Insurance fosters career development through access to continuing education, tuition assistance, and exposure to cross-functional projects. Senior adjusters benefit from leadership visibility and collaboration opportunities, empowering them to influence innovative claims solutions within a supportive environment.
At Nautilus, the role emphasizes a client-first mindset combined with modern digital tools and hybrid work flexibility. The company’s focus on high-net-worth clientele and quality vendor management sets it apart, offering adjusters a dynamic, technology-enabled claims experience.
Senior Property Claims Adjusters in Scottsdale typically earn between $85,000 and $110,000 annually, depending on experience and company size. Roles at companies like Nautilus Insurance offer competitive compensation coupled with benefits such as profit sharing and 401(k) plans.
Scottsdale offers a blend of a thriving insurance market and an appealing lifestyle with a warm climate. The demand for skilled adjusters is rising, making it a promising location for career growth in property claims adjustment within respected companies like Nautilus Insurance.
Proficiency with claims estimating software such as Symbility, along with automated claims management systems, is essential. Nautilus emphasizes leveraging these technologies to streamline claim handling and improve service quality for high-net-worth clients.