Casualty Claims Adjuster Tier III
Company : Nautilus Insurance Company
Location : Scottsdale, AZ
Job Type : Full Time / Part Time
Date Posted : 2 January 2026
Company Details
Berkley One is a modern insurance provider for a modern generation of affluence. We serve clients who live dynamic, adventurous lives and expect their insurance experience to match. Our mission is to deliver highly personalized risk and claims management through a blend of expert independent agents, cutting-edge digital tools, and the strength of the Berkley brand.
Why Join Us?
At Berkley One, you’ll be part of a forward-thinking team that’s reimagining personal insurance. We’re building solutions that are as sophisticated and agile as the clients we serve—individuals and families who value innovation, simplicity, and exceptional service. You’ll collaborate with passionate professionals, leverage modern technology, and help shape the future of our industry.
What We Value
- A client-first mindset with a passion for delivering exceptional experiences
- Curiosity, creativity, and a drive to challenge the status quo
- Collaboration across disciplines to build smarter, more intuitive solutions
- Integrity, expertise, and a commitment to excellence
Join us in creating a new standard in personal insurance—where protection meets possibility.
This role will be based in our Phoenix, AZ or Wilmington, DE office. We offer a hybrid work schedule with 4 days in the office; and 1 day remote where it makes sense to do so.
#LI-AV1 #LI-HYBRID
The Company is an equal employment opportunity employer.
Responsibilities
The Casualty Claims Adjuster is a key contributor to the Berkley One brand. The position requires Liability, Injury and Auto Physical Damage claim technical, organizational and time management skills, along with self-direction and exceptional customer service. This position is responsible for quality, timely handling and resolution of moderately complex claims in a professional manner.
What you can expect:
- Culture of innovation, teamwork, supportive colleagues and leaders willing to invest in talent
- Internal mobility opportunities
- Visibility to senior leaders and partnership with cross functional teams
- Opportunity to impact change
- Benefits – competitive compensation, paid time off, comprehensive wellness benefits and programs, employer funded health savings account, profit sharing, 401k, paid parental leave, employee stock purchase plan, tuition assistance and professional continuing education
We'll count on you to:
- Handle first and third-party personal lines auto, homeowner liability, bodily injury, first party medical/PIP, and auto physical damage claims of moderate complexity.
- Appropriately manage claims through coverage analysis, investigation, reserving and resolution
- Identify and address coverage issues, complete investigation to determine cause & exposure, set timely reserves and develop detailed action plans
- Negotiate claim settlements with attorneys and unrepresented claimants
- Establish validity of claims submitted for payment through coverage research and contact with policyholders, claimants and outside parties
- Research and locate additional information and documentation to investigate, evaluate and properly resolve claims
- Write denial letters, reservation of rights, coverage disclaimers and other correspondence
- Work with defense counsel and coverage counsel as needed.
- Maintain an effective diary system and document claim file activities in accordance with established procedures
- Pro-actively manage file inventory to ensure timely resolution of cases
- Deliver exceptional customer service to meet the needs of the insured, agent and all internal and external customers
- Perform administrative functions such as expense accounts and time off reporting as required
Qualifications
- Bachelors degree or equivalent work experience
- Minimum 3 years of experience handling injury insurance claims with an emphasis in working with High Net Worth customers and experience with automated claims systems
- You will also actively participate on CAT duty when needed
- Broad knowledge of auto, bodily injury, UM/UIM, and first party injury claims.
- Agile learner who can quickly absorb information and apply it to current business situations.
- Incredible empathy and understanding of the needs of customers, both insureds and their agents alike. You will be an excellent, pro-active advocate for Berkley One customers and are passionate about their brand experience
- Exceptional oral and written communication skills. Your communication style is flexible to the situation. You communicate clearly and with a purpose
- Calm under pressure. You have excellent organizational and negotiation skills, integrity, and great follow-through on tasks. You are comfortable challenging norms while working collaboratively with colleagues at all levels of the organization
- You have a strong sense of accountability, fun and adventure
- Natural curiosity. You love learning how things work and you are always looking for innovative improvements
Additional Company Details
We do not accept any unsolicited resumes from external recruiting agencies or firms. The company offers a competitive compensation plan and robust benefits package for full time regular employees. The actual salary for this position will be determined by a number of factors, including the scope, complexity and location of the role; the skills, education, training, credentials and experience of the candidate; and other conditions of employment.Sponsorship Details
Sponsorship not Offered for this RoleRelated Jobs
Top trending job titles hiring now
Popular Searches for Claims Adjuster
Frequently asked questions
Scottsdale's insurance sector shows moderate competition for advanced claims adjusters like Tier III. Demand is steady due to the region's affluent demographics, requiring adjusters skilled in handling complex casualty claims with high client expectations. Networking locally can enhance opportunities in this specialized field.
Adjusters in Scottsdale often navigate claims involving luxury assets and high-net-worth individuals, demanding precise liability assessments and negotiations. The region’s dynamic lifestyle necessitates adaptability and superior customer service to meet clients’ sophisticated insurance needs.
Certifications like AIC (Associate in Claims) or CPCU (Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter) are highly regarded locally. These credentials demonstrate expertise in casualty and liability claims, aligning well with Scottsdale’s market expectations for senior adjusters managing complex insurance cases.
At Nautilus, adjusters engage deeply with affluent clients, combining tech-driven claims handling with personalized service. The company fosters innovation and collaboration, expecting Tier III adjusters to deliver both technical accuracy and exceptional customer experiences in liability and injury claims.
Nautilus encourages internal mobility, offering Tier III adjusters chances to advance into leadership or specialized claims roles. Exposure to senior management and cross-functional projects supports professional development within a culture valuing creativity and client-first solutions.
Yes, Nautilus supports a hybrid schedule with four days onsite in Phoenix or Wilmington offices and one remote day, balancing collaboration and flexibility. This setup suits adjusters managing complex casualty claims who benefit from both direct team interaction and focused remote work.
In Scottsdale, Tier III Casualty Claims Adjusters earn approximately $75,000 to $95,000 annually, influenced by experience and claim complexity. This range reflects the specialized skills required for high-net-worth client claims and the region’s standard of living.
Tier III adjusters handle moderately complex personal liability and injury claims, negotiate settlements with attorneys, and author specialized correspondence like denial letters. Their responsibilities extend beyond basic claim review to include strategic coverage analysis and advanced customer advocacy.
Negotiation expertise is vital when resolving disputes with attorneys or unrepresented claimants, especially in bodily injury and liability cases. Tier III adjusters must balance fair settlement offers with company interests, requiring tactful communication and in-depth claim evaluation.
Understanding auto, bodily injury, UM/UIM, and first-party injury claims is essential. Proficiency with automated claims systems enables efficient investigation and reserving, supporting timely resolutions while maintaining compliance and high-quality customer service.