Claims Manager
Company : Nautilus Insurance Company
Location : Scottsdale, AZ
Job Type : Full Time / Part Time
Date Posted : 10 January 2026
Company Details
As an elite Excess and Surplus Lines market, Nautilus Insurance Group offers commercial property and casualty insurance solutions to appointed wholesale surplus lines producers countrywide. We have specialized in providing these solutions for more than 35 years.
We have more flexible policy terms and premium rates on a non-admitted basis. Our focus is small to medium Property and Casualty risks on both an admitted and a non-admitted basis.
Our offerings are distributed through partnerships with appointed wholesale surplus lines producers. Our relationships are defined by mutual success, speed to market, customer-centric focus and an expanded appetite.
Coverage placed by Nautilus Insurance Group is provided by Nautilus Insurance Company and Great Divide Insurance Company, both W. R. Berkley Corporation members with A.M. Best (Superior) A+ XV ratings.
Benefit Highlights:
- Paid Parental Leave! At Nautilus, we offer Childbirth Recovery Leave as well as Primary Caregiver Leave, for up to a maximum of 12 weeks of paid leave.
- Nautilus offers Medical, Dental, and Vision coverage options, along with Flexible Spending Accounts (FSA) and Health Savings Accounts (HSA) choices
- We help our employees feel secure by providing a 401(k) program, profit sharing, stock purchase plan, life insurance, and travel accident insurance options.
- One of our core values is “Committed to Serve” and these aren’t idle words. We provide every employee one paid day off per year to volunteer at a local charity. That’s serving with a smile!
- We take risk management excellence and your professional growth seriously by offering Tuition Assistance and Industry-Related Education and Exam programs.
- Can you hear us now? Employees are eligible for special cell phone service discounts with Verizon and AT&T. We’ve got a plum position for you! We participate in the Plum Benefits program offering employees cost-free access to thousands of exclusive travel and entertainment discounts.
- Flexible work arrangements, including working from home 1 day a week.
Responsibilities
The Claims Manager is the front-line management position responsible for the direct supervision of the Claims staff at all Examiner levels. Demonstration of strong leadership qualities and professionalism is essential.
This role can be in any of these three offices: Scottsdale AZ, Richmond VA, or West Chester OH, or remote for a highly qualfied candidate.
- Manages the entire employment cycle for all direct report positions including but not limited to recruiting, onboarding, training, engaging, managing compensation, mentoring, managing performance (reviews & corrective action), and terminations.
- Performs regular file reviews and audits to determine compliance with best practices.
- Responsible for controlling expenses within the Department guidelines.
- Facilitates and promotes consistent, positive Department financial results by actively strategizing with and providing appropriate guidance and authority to technical staff. Requires technical knowledge and experience, including an understanding of coverage and contract law, investigation, legal liability, litigation and reserving.
- Understands and utilizes existing technology resources and data to measure and monitor financial and performance trends.
- Responsibility for various projects related to achieving Department goals (i.e., cost management, quality assurance, SIU, training and development, etc.)
- Regular participation in the interviewing process for potential new hire candidates.
- Occasional responsibility for handling claims that are very complex and/or involve sensitive or confidential information.
- Reviews and approves coverage letters and responses to regulatory agency inquiries.
- Reviews and approves Large Loss Reports.
- Other duties as assigned
Qualifications
- Must have at least twelve (12) years of insurance experience, with significant experience in commercial general liablity claims handling.
- Must have intermediate knowledge of Microsoft Office.
- Guidewire ClaimsCenter experience a plus.
- Bachelor’s degree (B.A.) from four-year college or university; or one to two years related experience and/or training; or equivalent combination of education and experience.
- CPCU, AIC or completion of other insurance-related classes is preferred.
Additional Company Details
The Company is an equal employment opportunity employer We do not accept any unsolicited resumes from external recruiting agencies or firms. The company offers a competitive compensation plan and robust benefits package for full time regular employees. The actual salary for this position will be determined by a number of factors, including the scope, complexity and location of the role; the skills, education, training, credentials and experience of the candidate; and other conditions of employment.Sponsorship Details
Sponsorship not Offered for this RoleRelated Jobs
Top trending job titles hiring now
Popular Searches for Claims Manager
Frequently asked questions
Thriving as a Claims Manager in Scottsdale demands strong leadership skills such as decisiveness, effective team mentoring, and strategic problem-solving. These traits help in managing claims staff efficiently while navigating the commercial insurance landscape unique to the Scottsdale market.
Unlike Claims Analysts who primarily assess claims data, a Claims Manager oversees the entire claims process, including staff supervision and policy compliance. This leadership role requires broader expertise in contract law and litigation, guiding teams to optimize claims resolution.
Claims management roles in Scottsdale offer upward mobility towards senior leadership, such as Chief Claims Officer positions, especially within companies like Nautilus Insurance. Continuous education and certifications can accelerate advancement in this competitive insurance hub.
Nautilus Insurance facilitates flexible work arrangements, including remote options for qualified candidates and one day per week working from home. These policies foster a balanced lifestyle while maintaining high performance in claims operations.
The company’s commitment to service and community engagement shapes Claims Managers’ roles by encouraging leadership that values mentorship, ethical claims handling, and active participation in volunteer initiatives, enriching both professional and personal development.
Claims Managers in Scottsdale can expect an average annual salary ranging between $95,000 and $120,000, reflecting the region’s demand and the specialized expertise required for managing complex commercial insurance claims effectively.
Scottsdale’s growing commercial property market and the prevalence of surplus lines insurance contribute to steady demand for experienced Claims Managers, making the area competitive but promising for professionals with strong leadership and claims expertise.
Employers in Scottsdale often favor candidates holding CPCU or AIC designations due to their advanced knowledge of insurance principles, which are highly relevant to managing commercial general liability claims in this region.
Applicants should show proficiency in claims supervision, knowledge of contract law, and experience with tools like Guidewire ClaimsCenter. Strong communication and financial oversight capabilities are also critical for success at Nautilus.
Nautilus leverages data analytics and platforms like Guidewire ClaimsCenter enabling Claims Managers to monitor performance trends and financial metrics, which improves decision-making and streamlines claims management workflows.