Risevoic LogoRisevoic

  • HOME
  • ABOUT US
  • CONTACT US
Nautilus Insurance Company

Underwriting Manager - Small Commercial

Company : Nautilus Insurance Company

Location : Glen Allen, VA, 23060

Job Type : Full Time / Part Time

Date Posted : 4 January 2026

Company Details

Berkley Mid-Atlantic Group (BMAG) is a property and casualty insurance provider serving the Mid-Atlantic. We are a member of W. R. Berkley Corporation, one of the largest commercial lines property casualty insurance holding companies in the United States. With the resources of a large Fortune 500® corporation and the ability to operate with the closeness and flexibility of a small company, we exclusively work with select independent agents to insure the future of business.

Our culture is one that empowers employees to question the status quo and seek innovative ways to continue to exceed the expectations of our customers. We practice collaboration, creativity, and teamwork on a daily basis, with a commitment to innovation and high performance.

Company URL:  https://www.wrbmag.com/

The company is an equal opportunity employer.

Responsibilities

The Underwriting Manager - Small Commercial leads an assigned Commercial Lines Underwriting team. Responsible for profitability, growth and retention of new and renewal business.

  • Manage an assigned commercial underwriting function and staff through delegation of underwriting authority.  Ensures adherence to Letter of Authority and other Underwriting standards and guidelines.
  • Monitors the risk acceptability, pricing adequacy and classification accuracy of accounts to ensure profitability and managed growth of business.  Consults with underwriters and Corporate Underwriting on risk acceptability, coverages, pricing, terms and conditions.
  • Ensures quality of risk through passing audit scores for the team.
  • Underwrites accounts exceeding authority level of underwriting staff by analyzing applications, risk services reports, Motor Vehicle Reports (MVRs), financial reports, etc.  Determines accurate classification of business, policy contract forms and pricing of risk.  Refers accounts to Corporate Underwriting, as needed, based on established guidelines.
  • Hires, trains, and develops a high performing team of Small Commercial Underwriting professionals through leadership acumen and execution. Demonstrates genuine care and delivers daily coaching to staff and leaders in order to further develop their skills set and performance for current and future roles.
  • Provides frequent and specific constructive feedback on a regular basis.  Contributes to the organization’s success by developing business unit and individual performance goals and measuring results. Provides recognition and acknowledgement of key achievements.
  • Conducts quarterly underwriting file quality reviews and shares results with the Small Commercial Segment Leader and corporate underwriting.  Develops and implements action plans in response to file quality reviews. 
  • Monitors service levels associated with new business opportunities, renewal issuance, and endorsements
  • Participate on projects and initiatives as assigned by senior leadership.
  • Utilize an innovative, problem-solving approach with all situations – challenging the status quo and elevating messages as needed, even when difficult.
  • Coach to sales commitments, and develop employee development plans for all direct reports.
  • Review claims activity, loss control surveys, and inspection reports for compliance with existing policies, handling exceptions as required and recommending improvements.
  • Provide support to ensure accurate and timely servicing of accounts.
  • Collaborate with other departments to resolve policy issues and adherence to service standards.
  • Research, formulate and implement solutions for complex issues and accounts.
  • Assist Underwriters in determining final coverages and pricing for commercial risks within assigned authority level.
  • Proactively work to coach underwriters in the art of agency relationships – creating clarity around agency segmentation, coaching to initial conversations, retention, follow-up, all with a focus on long-term profitability and growth.
  • Help underwriters understand expectations around knowing, contacting, and deepening relationships with key producers.
  • Mentor less experienced underwriters and serve as a resource for others within the department as needed.
  • Successfully build, manage and execute a New Business Pipeline for self as well helping assigned underwriters build, manage, and successfully execute a New Business Pipeline.
  • Understand and communicate Berkley Mid-Atlantic’s strategic plan, tying into the department and build into employee development plans.
  • Periodically review and refine underwriting best practices as needed.
  • Perform other duties as assigned.
  • Travel as necessary.

Qualifications

  •  7+ years’ relevant experience in Commercial Lines Underwriting.
  • Knowledge of underwriting processes, coverages, and tools to gather and evaluate information in order to reach appropriate decisions on renewals and new business.
  • Demonstrated understanding of pricing components and rating methodology.
  • Proven ability to interact and communicate with all levels of internal colleagues and external business partners.
  • Track record of delivering accurate results consistently meeting deadlines.
  • Strong problem-solving ability; reasoning and judgment/decision-making skills.
  • Demonstrated ability to listen reflectively and show courage in elevating difficult conversations.
  • Possess AU, ARMS, CIC, CPCU, or other equivalent insurance designation preferred.
  • Well organized, efficient and able to work independently while also able to bring a team together with others in the organization, working collaboratively for the greater good.
  • Ability to handle multiple tasks and efficiently prioritize.
  • Ability to work with others in a cooperative manner.
  • Bachelor’s Degree preferred or equivalent combination of education and experience.
  • MS Excel, Word, PowerPoint proficiency.

Additional Company Details

We do not accept any unsolicited resumes from external recruiting agencies or firms. The company offers a competitive compensation plan and robust benefits package for full time regular employees. The actual salary for this position will be determined by a number of factors, including the scope, complexity and location of the role; the skills, education, training, credentials and experience of the candidate; and other conditions of employment.

Sponsorship Details

Sponsorship not Offered for this Role

Related Jobs

Underwriting Manager

Nautilus Insurance Company

location_icon Scottsdale, AZ
APPLY NOW

Territory Underwriting Manager

Nautilus Insurance Company

location_icon Homewood, AL
APPLY NOW

Underwriting Manager - Northeast US

Nautilus Insurance Company

location_icon Scottsdale, AZ
APPLY NOW

E&S Underwriting Manager

Nautilus Insurance Company

location_icon Jacksonville, FL
APPLY NOW

E&S Underwriting Manager, Renewal

Nautilus Insurance Company

location_icon Scottsdale, AZ
APPLY NOW

Manager, Underwriting Services

Nautilus Insurance Company

location_icon Minneapolis, MN
APPLY NOW

Top trending job titles hiring now

Underwriter

Senior underwriter

Underwriting director

Underwriting specialist

Mortgage underwriter

Regional underwriting manager

Underwriting consultant

Manager, underwriting

Senior underwriting manager

Account manager

Popular Searches for Underwriting Manager

Mortgage underwriter jobs

Frequently asked questions

In Glen Allen, VA, holding designations like CPCU, ARM, or AU can significantly enhance an underwriting manager's credibility. These certifications demonstrate advanced expertise in commercial lines underwriting, aligning with local industry standards and improving competitiveness within the Mid-Atlantic insurance sector.

The Glen Allen insurance market shows increasing demand for seasoned underwriting managers, especially in small commercial lines. Growth in regional businesses and a focus on risk management elevate the need for leaders who can drive profitability while mentoring underwriting teams effectively.

Small Commercial underwriting specialists excel in evaluating risks for smaller business policies, requiring nuanced risk assessment, pricing acumen, and relationship-building skills tailored to commercial clients. They navigate complex classifications and maintain profitability while managing diverse coverages unique to small enterprises.

Daily tasks range from evaluating high-risk accounts beyond team authority to coaching underwriters, reviewing audit scores, and collaborating across departments. Prioritizing risk acceptability and pricing accuracy while fostering team development defines the dynamic nature of this managerial role.

Professionals often advance from underwriters to managerial roles, then to senior underwriting leadership or commercial lines directors. Gaining expertise in pricing strategies, team leadership, and strategic planning opens pathways to broader commercial insurance management positions.

Nautilus embeds underwriting managers into strategic initiatives by aligning their team goals with company growth targets. Managers contribute to refining underwriting practices, participate in leadership projects, and champion innovation to uphold Nautilus's commitment to high performance in the Mid-Atlantic region.

At Nautilus, balancing the agility of a smaller firm with Fortune 500 scale resources means underwriting managers must innovate constantly. They handle complex risk assessments while nurturing independent agent relationships, necessitating adaptability within a collaborative but high-expectation environment.

Typically, underwriting managers in Glen Allen, VA, earn between $95,000 and $125,000 annually. Factors influencing pay include experience, certifications like CPCU, and the scope of commercial lines managed. Nautilus Insurance offers competitive compensation aligned with regional market standards.

Glen Allen offers moderate commuting options with proximity to Richmond's urban amenities. Traffic congestion is manageable, supporting reasonable work-life balance for underwriting managers who may occasionally travel but benefit from a less hectic environment compared to larger metro areas.

  1. Home
  2. Companies
  3. Nautilus Insurance Company Jobs Hiring Near Me
  4. Underwriting Manager - Small Commercial job in Glen Allen, VA, US

Risevoic Logo Risevoic

Making professional connections is simple and effective.

emailadmin@risevoic.com

phone+1 470-403-3141

locationSpaces Davis Square, 240 Elm Street, 3rd Floor, Somerville, MA, US-02144

Quick Links

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Blogs

Top Cities Hiring

  • Portland, OR
  • Chicago, IL
  • Bronx, NY
  • Phoenix, AZ
  • Dallas, TX

Utility

  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy

© 2025 Risevoic.
All Rights Reserved.