Litigation Specialist
Company : Nautilus Insurance Company
Location : Scottsdale, AZ
Job Type : Full Time / Part Time
Date Posted : 5 January 2026
Company Details
As an elite Excess and Surplus Lines market, Nautilus Insurance Group offers commercial property and casualty insurance solutions to appointed wholesale surplus lines producers countrywide. We have specialized in providing these solutions for more than 35 years.
We have more flexible policy terms and premium rates on a non-admitted basis. Our focus is small to medium Property and Casualty risks on both an admitted and a non-admitted basis. Our offerings are distributed through partnerships with appointed wholesale surplus lines producers. Our relationships are defined by mutual success, speed to market, customer-centric focus and an expanded appetite.
Coverage placed by Nautilus Insurance Group is provided by Nautilus Insurance Company and Great Divide Insurance Company, both W. R. Berkley Corporation members with A.M. Best (Superior) A+ XV ratings.
Benefit Highlights:
- Paid Parental Leave! At Nautilus, we offer Childbirth Recovery Leave as well as Primary Caregiver Leave, for up to a maximum of 12 weeks of paid leave.
- Nautilus offers Medical, Dental, and Vision coverage options, along with Flexible Spending Accounts (FSA) and Health Savings Accounts (HSA) choices
- We help our employees feel secure by providing a 401(k) program, profit sharing, stock purchase plan, life insurance, and travel accident insurance options.
- One of our core values is “Committed to Serve” and these aren’t idle words. We provide every employee one paid day off per year to volunteer at a local charity. That’s serving with a smile!
- We take risk management excellence and your professional growth seriously by offering Tuition Assistance and Industry-Related Education and Exam programs.
- Can you hear us now? Employees are eligible for special cell phone service discounts with Verizon and AT&T. We’ve got a plum position for you! We participate in the Plum Benefits program offering employees cost-free access to thousands of exclusive travel and entertainment discounts.
- Flexible work arrangements
- On site newly renovated fitness center - free to use for employees. Yoga and other classes available for a nominal fee.
Responsibilities
Nautilus insurance is seeking a Claims Litigation Specialist. This role can be located in our Scottsdale office on a hybrid schedule, or remotely for a highly qualified candidate.
The Litigation Specialist’s job function includes efficiently and effectively handling advanced-level, primarily litigated, commercial first-property and/or third-party general liability losses in a “paperless” environment. An ability to communicate both verbally and in written form in a prompt, courteous and professional manner is essential.
- Review and set up new loss assignments in a timely manner in compliance with department guidelines and best practices.
- Establish appropriate initial loss and expense reserves and continue to regularly evaluate the file for adequacy, accuracy and adherence to reserving guidelines.
- Analyze and interpret policy language in conjunction with specific loss facts to reach appropriate coverage decisions.
- Draft frequent and complex coverage correspondence, including reservation of rights and coverage disclaimers in compliance with various state statutes and regulations.
- Compose a variety of other detailed correspondence to insureds, claimants, attorneys, agents and Regulatory agencies.
- Proactively manage primarily litigated claim files from inception to closure, including identification and investigation of coverage, liability and damage issues, determination and efficient execution of an appropriate plan of action, and prompt, economical file resolution, in compliance with department guidelines and best practices.
- Appropriately and clearly document all claim file activity, including current strategy, plan of action and exit plan in file notes.
- Consistently demonstrate comprehensive coverage analysis, investigation, evaluation and negotiation skills at an advanced level.
- Direct and control the activities and costs of numerous outside vendors including defense counsel and coverage counsel, experts and independent adjusters.
- Effectively present and discuss loss facts and issues in roundtable discussions to peers and members of management at all levels.
- Compose and transmit in a regular and timely basis frequent Large Loss Reports and other detailed reporting documents as appropriate.
- Manage and monitor file caseload through the use of various resources.
- Obtain all required state adjuster licenses and maintain them as required via compliance with mandatory continuing education requirements.
- Serve as a technical resource within the department through mentoring and knowledge-sharing, whether one-on-one, in small groups, or presentations to larger groups.
- Meet with intern personnel and others as needed to provide job function overview and/or specific subject-matter training.
- Occasional participation in projects and initiatives lead by other departments and/or W. R. Berkley companies, including audits, workshops, focus groups, task forces, etc.
- Initiate appropriate communication with members of management and other department.
- Attend internal and external seminars and other training events and provide feedback to peers and/or members of management.
#LI-RS1
#LI-Remote
Qualifications
- A minimum of fifteen years of experience in property and casualty claims.
- Excess and Surplus lines background preferred.
- Construction defect experience beneficial.
- Commercial General Liability experience is required.
- CPCU, AIC, AEI or other insurance-related classes/designations preferred.
- High School Diploma is required.
- Certifications are required by state.
Additional Company Details
The Company is an equal employment opportunity employer. We do not accept any unsolicited resumes from external recruiting agencies or firms. The company offers a competitive compensation plan and robust benefits package for full time regular employees. The actual salary for this position will be determined by a number of factors, including the scope, complexity and location of the role; the skills, education, training, credentials and experience of the candidate; and other conditions of employment.Related Jobs
Senior Claim Litigation Specialist - Construction Defect
Nautilus Insurance Company
Top trending job titles hiring now
Frequently asked questions
In Scottsdale, a Litigation Specialist often handles intricate commercial property and casualty claims by analyzing policy details alongside specific loss facts. They coordinate with vendors and attorneys to ensure efficient, economical resolutions while adhering to state laws and company guidelines, especially within surplus lines insurance frameworks.
Certifications such as CPCU, AIC, or AEI are highly regarded for Litigation Specialists in Arizona. Additionally, maintaining state-required adjuster licenses with ongoing education ensures compliance and enhances expertise in handling complex liability and coverage issues in this regulated market.
A Litigation Specialist can grow into senior claims roles, lead litigation teams, or transition toward managerial positions overseeing multiple commercial lines. Nautilus’s emphasis on professional growth, including tuition assistance and certifications, supports upward mobility in excess and surplus lines claims management.
Yes, Nautilus Insurance offers a hybrid work schedule at their Scottsdale office and allows highly qualified candidates to work remotely. This flexibility aligns with their focus on employee well-being and adapting to modern work-life balance demands in the insurance litigation field.
Nautilus provides benefits such as paid parental leave, flexible work arrangements, and onsite fitness facilities. These perks help Litigation Specialists manage professional demands alongside personal commitments, enhancing job satisfaction and productivity in Scottsdale’s competitive market.
Experienced Litigation Specialists in Scottsdale typically earn between $90,000 and $120,000 annually, depending on expertise, certifications, and company scale. Nautilus Insurance’s competitive compensation package reflects the specialized skills required for commercial claims litigation in the surplus lines sector.
Nautilus’s culture emphasizes commitment to service, collaborative problem-solving, and professional development. Litigation Specialists benefit from mentorship opportunities and active participation in cross-department projects, fostering a dynamic environment where legal expertise directly supports strategic risk management.
Navigating complex coverage interpretations and managing multiple outside vendors can be demanding. Litigation Specialists must balance prompt claim resolution with regulatory compliance and cost control, especially within a paperless environment focused on commercial property and casualty disputes.
Scottsdale’s growing commercial insurance market drives steady demand for skilled Litigation Specialists, particularly those with excess and surplus lines expertise. Local employers seek candidates adept at managing complex liability claims and navigating Arizona’s regulatory landscape.
Competition is moderate to high due to the specialized nature of commercial claims in surplus lines insurance. Candidates with extensive experience, relevant certifications, and strong negotiation skills are preferred, making continuous professional development crucial for standing out locally.