Executive Underwriter
Company : Nautilus Insurance Company
Location : Cincinnati, OH, 45236
Job Type : Full Time / Part Time
Date Posted : 12 January 2026
Company Details
Berkley Mid-Atlantic Group (BMAG) is a property and casualty insurance provider serving the Mid-Atlantic. We are a member of W. R. Berkley Corporation, one of the largest commercial lines property casualty insurance holding companies in the United States. With the resources of a large Fortune 500® corporation and the ability to operate with the closeness and flexibility of a small company, we exclusively work with select independent agents to insure the future of business.
Our culture is one that empowers employees to question the status quo and seek innovative ways to continue to exceed the expectations of our customers. We practice collaboration, creativity, and teamwork on a daily basis, with a commitment to innovation and high performance.
Company URL: https://www.wrbmag.com/
The company is an equal opportunity employer.
Responsibilities
Strategic Technical Underwriting
- Independently underwrite complex middle market risks across multiple lines of business, including Property, General Liability, Auto, and Umbrella, and Workers’ Compensation, with a focus on profitability and alignment with underwriting appetite.
- Apply advanced risk assessment techniques and industry knowledge to evaluate exposures, structure coverage solutions, and make sound underwriting decisions.
- Collaborate with internal partners such as Loss Control, Claims, and Actuarial to incorporate technical insights into account-level strategies.
- Maintain a high standard of underwriting discipline, documentation, and compliance with regulatory and internal guidelines.
- Monitor market trends, emerging risks, and competitive positioning to inform underwriting approach and contribute to product refinement.
- Serve as a technical resource to peers and contribute to continuous improvement of underwriting practices through knowledge sharing and feedback.
Enterprise Portfolio Management & Internal Collaboration
- Oversee performance of a multi-regional or national book of business.
- Analyze portfolio trends and emerging risks to inform strategic decisions.
- Collaborate with actuarial, finance, and product teams to develop pricing and segmentation strategies.
- Lead quarterly business reviews and contribute to enterprise planning.
- Partner closely with BMAG and other WRB companies to share market intelligence, align on product development opportunities, and identify enterprise-wide solutions.
Sales & Distribution Execution
- Actively engage with agents and brokers to drive new business production and retention within the middle market segment.
- Conduct in-person and virtual sales calls, articulating the company’s value proposition and underwriting appetite.
- Identify and pursue cross-sell and up-sell opportunities in collaboration with distribution partners.
- Deliver customized solutions by leveraging product knowledge and aligning offerings with client needs.
- Participate in industry events, agency meetings, and client presentations to build visibility and strengthen relationships.
- Track and analyze producer performance to inform territory strategies and drive targeted outreach.
- Collaborate with internal stakeholders (e.g., Marketing, Product, Loss Control) to support field initiatives and enhance market competitiveness.
Success Factors:
- Strategic thinker with a bias for action and innovation.
- Influential leader who inspires trust and drives change.
- Deep understanding of market dynamics and competitive positioning.
- Passionate about talent development and underwriting excellence.
- Collaborative mindset with a strong enterprise orientation.
Qualifications
- Bachelor’s Degree or equivalent industry experience and training. Advanced professional insurance designations (CPCU, CIC, etc.) preferred.
- 7+ years of commercial lines sales and underwriting experience with extensive knowledge of industry practices, trends, and a proven sales track record.
- Strong interpersonal relationship skills, effective communication skills necessary to build rapport, add value and effectively problem-solve with agency partners, principals, producers, and staff.
- Valid driver’s license for travel
- Strong technical acumen in commercial insurance sales and underwriting, and the ability to apply it to effectively interact with internal departments to meet customer needs and solve customer issues.
- Solid understanding of agency prospecting, planning, incentives, and agency performance accountability.
- Strong written and verbal communication skills.
- Self-motivated and able to work independently with minimal supervision, delivering results for agencies and the company.
- Working knowledge and familiarity with assigned territory, agencies, and competitors is preferred.
- Ability to travel as needed within the territory; overnight stays may be occasional.
Additional Company Details
We do not accept any unsolicited resumes from external recruiting agencies or firms. The company offers a competitive compensation plan and robust benefits package for full time regular employees. The actual salary for this position will be determined by a number of factors, including the scope, complexity and location of the role; the skills, education, training, credentials and experience of the candidate; and other conditions of employment.Sponsorship Details
Sponsorship not Offered for this RoleRelated Jobs
Top trending job titles hiring now
Popular Searches for Executive Underwriter
Frequently asked questions
In Cincinnati, designations like CPCU or CIC stand out for Executive Underwriters, enhancing credibility and technical expertise. These certifications align well with local industry standards, helping professionals navigate complex risks and meet regulatory demands effectively within the competitive property and casualty insurance sector.
Managing a diverse book across regions requires strategic analysis of market trends and risk exposures. Executive Underwriters must blend technical underwriting with enterprise-wide collaboration, ensuring profitability while adapting to regional nuances and regulatory variations, which elevates their impact beyond routine policy assessments.
Nautilus Insurance emphasizes innovation and teamwork within a Fortune 500® framework, offering Executive Underwriters a unique blend of large-scale resources and nimble decision-making. This environment fosters creative risk solutions and client-focused underwriting strategies tailored to the middle market segment.
Success demands a visionary mindset paired with strong influence skills to drive change across underwriting teams and distribution channels. At Nautilus, fostering trust and promoting collaboration while navigating complex commercial lines risks is critical for sustaining growth and underwriting excellence.
Cincinnati’s insurance sector maintains steady demand for seasoned Executive Underwriters, with moderate competition fueled by established companies and regional insurers. Candidates with solid commercial lines expertise, local market knowledge, and advanced credentials enjoy a distinct edge in this market.
Given Cincinnati’s urban-suburban spread, Executive Underwriters often balance in-office collaboration with client meetings across the region. Occasional overnight travel may be required to service multi-regional accounts, making flexibility and a valid driver’s license essential for seamless territory management.
Executive Underwriters in Cincinnati typically earn between $95,000 and $130,000 annually, depending on experience and negotiation. Factors such as portfolio complexity, certifications, and proven sales success can push compensation toward the higher end within the property and casualty insurance domain.
Executive Underwriters excel in synthesizing complex risk data across multiple lines, applying strategic pricing, and leading portfolio performance reviews. Their advanced communication skills enable effective collaboration with actuaries, claims, and brokers, setting them apart through enterprise-wide impact and leadership.
Deep familiarity with Cincinnati’s commercial landscape allows Executive Underwriters to anticipate emerging risks and tailor coverage solutions effectively. By integrating regional economic trends and competitive positioning insights, underwriters can optimize portfolio profitability and client satisfaction.
Nautilus Insurance fosters continuous learning and innovation for Executive Underwriters, encouraging participation in cross-functional teams and leadership initiatives. The company supports professional growth through exposure to enterprise planning and market intelligence sharing within the WR Berkley network.